
You may have seen that the Supreme Court has issued a ruling that basically states that there were student loans that could be forgiven. This only effects a few thousand of the millions of student loans out there, and doesn’t effect most of the colleges and universities in the country. There were only a handful of schools that were told they had to cancel the loans, and it had nothing to do with Biden’s fiasco.
There’s a LOT more to it than that.
There were three colleges (not necessarily universities) that had asked the highest court in the land to disallow the forgiveness of debts, but not for the same reasons as the Biden administration argued. Everglades College, Lincoln Educational Service Corp. and American National University, filed suit with the high court seeking a halt to an already agreed upon class action settlement that had nothing to do with Biden’s wiping out student loan debt.
This case dealt with students that had successfully argued they took out loans after receiving misleading or false information from the schools. There were about 3,800 loans that qualified to be erased, totaling about $6 billion, far less than what Biden is talking about.
The schools had been placed on a list of colleges that the federal government labeled as “Substantial Misconduct”.
Biden’s case has already been heard by the Supremes and their decision will be made public in a couple of months. Biden’s plan is skating on extremely thin ice on several issues. First of all, Biden himself (and the Department of Education) has issued the cancellation notice, not the Congress. Since the debt isn’t really going to be cancelled, but transferred to the taxpayers, making it a new tax. Biden doesn’t have the authority to tax anyone. That’s Congress’ job. And if Congress would have passed a bill prior to this past January saying they were going to go along with his plan, it would have been OK. It would have had the same weight as the whole Obamacare thing did back in 2012, when the Supreme Court issued a ruling stating that Congress has the right to tax people, and that’s what they were doing (even though Obama’s people swore up and down this wasn’t a tax).
There’s another fly in Biden’s ointment that is going to come back to bite him in the rear end. He has repeatedly said that he used the “Hero’s Act” as the reason why he was cancelling the debt. That was actually passed by Congress back a ways and gave service men and women who were serving their country overseas, the ability to defer their debts or in some cases cancel them altogether because they were serving their country and couldn’t tackle the day to day chore of bill paying. It had nothing to do with students. Biden applied the act to students because of COVID. Well, Biden himself has set May 11th as the end of the national emergency dealing with the COVID pandemic. So, one could reasonably argue that after that date, there is no reason to use the “Hero’s Act”, because after May 11th, there is no national emergency.
There is no reason in the world for the high court to rule in favor of Biden on this one. His was a calculated plan to try and get out the vote in the midterm by announcing that he was going to forgive billions in debt to students, and shifting that debt to the American public. What’s interesting is that about 70% of America was against this. The bill shifted the debt to hard working Americans who had either already paid off their student loan debts years ago, or had never gone to college and had to pay off the debts of someone that did, and would, according to most research make more money than the folks that got stuck paying off the bill.
Now, you add to that the fact that no one held a gun to these students’ heads and forced them to take out a loan to pay for college, nor to major in something like Women’s Studies, or Art History, or Philosophy, which gives them zero chance at getting a decent job in their field, and you’ve got a major problem that has been foisted on the public by the colleges and the universities who wanted to show how “woke” they were. Those three are just examples of some of the worthless degrees that are being offered by some rather prestigious universities these days. The problem is, there aren’t many jobs available for any of them!
And so, for the three colleges on the fed’s “Substantial Misconduct” list, they have to bite the bullet and erase the debt. More businesses masquerading as “higher learning institutions” are going to be going out of business!
Carry on world…you’re dismissed!
You must be logged in to post a comment.